Card image cap

Prohibition policy in Gujarat — a tragic farce?

Published on: Saturday, 18th July 2009 09:35 AM     By      Administrator




source: Reuters 


More than 130 people died after consuming bootleg liquor in Gujarat last week.


While prohibition is in place in Gujarat, liquor is often smuggled in from neighbouring states and people are forced to buy it at inflated prices.


What can the poor do? They cannot afford to buy branded alcohol so they consume illicit liquor. Plastic pouches called ‘potlis’ of illegally brewed liquor are available for as little as ten rupees.


Some have said that Gujarat’s prohibition policy encourages bootlegging. Liquor baron Vijay Mallya argues that apart from loss of revenue this leads to “illegal, unhygienic and unsupervised production of deadly cocktails which claim innocent lives.”


During the Great Depression, the ‘Noble Experiment’ prohibition policy in the United States was repealed just 14 years after the sale of alcohol was banned.


An article in the Foreign Policy magazine, a couple of years ago, argued:


“A ‘drug-free world,’ which the United Nations describes as a realistic goal, is no more attainable than an ‘alcohol-free world’ - and no one has talked about that with a straight face since the repeal of Prohibition in the United States in 1933.”


In the context of legalising use of marijuana, author and journalist Christopher Hitchens argues that:


“It’s beyond the competence of the state to decide a question like this. You can’t hope the government to go out and control what substance somebody puts in their own body. So even if I thought that marijuana was poisonous I would still say the government is not going to be able to stop it, so it shouldn’t try.”


In the 1990s, Andhra Pradesh took up and abandoned the prohibition policy in less than two years.


“Despite our best efforts, the prohibition-related offences, particularly illicit distillation and smuggling, have been steadily increasing in the state,” the state Excise minister said when the ban was being lifted.


source: Reuters